Knowledge Engineering in Architectural Education: Case Study of Sinan
Under the dust of 10 years; revisiting my master’s thesis. This paper introduces research about the Computer Aided Instruction (CAI) tool which is based on the master thesis of Tuğrul Yazar from Yıldız Technical University (YTU) Faculty of Architecture Computational Design Graduate Program (BOM). The thesis is named “Expert Systems for Architectural Education: The Expert System of Sinan Mosques” and was completed in 2003 under the supervision of Dr. Birgül Çolakoğlu. YTU Department of Computer Engineering supported this research by assigning the graduation project of Ali Murat Akkan as programming the prototype software. The educational tool developed in this research aims to teach Sinan’s mosque architecture by visualizing hypothetical mosque designs.
The project is based on learning by doing as it is the primary pedagogical approach for the institutional education of architecture. The proposed algorithm has a data flow including input and output parameter sets processed simultaneously. The input data is defined by the choices of the user (student) with the counseling of the tool. This is based on a sequential question-answer progress that develops a hypothetical design of the typological subject (in our case, it is a hypothetical Sinan mosque). The output data is processed by the tool, creating a digital model of the design, calculating the realism value, and suggesting automatic parameter inputs. Some more images from the thesis:
Here is a short paper [PDF File], produced from the thesis (in English) if you still want to read it; and here [PDF File] is the full text of the thesis (in Turkish). The funny part was the development of a computer tool, written by Ali Murat Akkan according to my algorithm definition. The tool was just a prototype but presented the possibilities of interdisciplinary work.
It is written in C (OpenGL library), and can be downloaded here (yes, still working!). As an interactive educational tool, this system aims to teach Sinan’s structural configurations, and historical periods in mosque architecture. This interactive system offers endless dynamic combinations and experiences about Sinan’s design methodology. It transforms students from passive learners to active self-learners.
Cite this post
Related Posts
Mihrimah Sultan Mosque
January 16, 2024
“Mihr-î Mah” in Ottoman Turkish translates to “The Sun and The Moon” in English. She was the most powerful imperial princess in Ottoman history according to historians. The Mihrimah Sultan Mosque is located in Üsküdar district of Istanbul. It was built for Mihrimah Sultan, the daughter of Kanuni Sultan Süleyman and Hürrem Sultan. It is one of the early works of the architect Mimar Sinan. Sinan supported the main dome with half domes on three sides, excluding the front facade….
Modeling a Baldequin
March 18, 2014
It is Baldequin (or Baldachin) in English, Baldeken, or Baldöken in Turkish. I don’t know which one is correct, but it is the name of a structural system of arches and pendentives that carry a dome. Sinan experimented with square, hexagonal, and octagonal variations in his mosque designs (as I developed parametric definitions of them in my 2003 master thesis (here)). Today, together with students we’ve modeled the system and tried to generate some variations by manipulating its parameters. Below…
Süleymaniye Mosque
February 25, 2013
Throne of my lonely niche, my wealth, my love, my moonlight.My most sincere friend, my confidant, my very existence, my Sultan, my one and only love.The most beautiful among the beautiful …My springtime, my merry-faced love, my daytime, my sweetheart, laughing leaf …My plants, my sweet, my rose, the one only who does not distress me in this room …My Istanbul, my Karaman, the earth of my AnatoliaMy Badakhshan, my Baghdad and KhorasanMy woman of the beautiful hair, my love…
Intra)/value
August 16, 2026
The group exhibition 2 Years 10 Meters, curated by Natalia Schmidt, opened on April 24, 2024, at the Cité Internationale des Arts in Paris. My name was also included in the exhibition due to the projection graphics in Didem Yalınay’s artwork Intra)/value. This was another step in Didem’s long-term project. She hated being called a “Digital Artist.” She produced wonderful works with Seçkin Maden. I was fortunate enough to accompany her as a modest collaborator on one of her pieces….
A New Chapter
August 1, 2026
The logic of computer programming has fascinated me since childhood. The same way of thinking also lies behind design mathematics, which is now my main field of interest. Searching for the simplicity behind things, looking for the fundamentals, and identifying the most meaningful basic elements has always been my greatest challenge. With this intention, Designcoding went online in 2011. I tried to share my research, some student work, and news. While learning computational geometry, I wanted to teach it as…