designcoding
About Table of Contents Keywords Monthly Archive
Support designcoding!

A Sartrean Criterion for AI Consciousness

August 4, 2026 | Discourses
#artificial-intelligence #consciousness #phenomenology #sartre

​In this article, I will attempt a small intervention in contemporary artificial intelligence discussions with an old philosophical example. Our hypothesis is this:

​”Artificial intelligence is very powerful at defining and reproducing existing patterns. However, experiencing that which is not there, absence, negation, and nothingness, as a lived condition belongs exclusively to human consciousness.”

Jean-Paul Sartre, in his famous “Cafe Example” from his 1943 work “Being and Nothingness“, describes the experience of someone entering a crowded cafe to find a friend Pierre. The space is filled with other people. But Pierre isn’t there. Eventually, for the seeker, the “non-being” of Pierre becomes a more dominant experience than all the “present” things in the room. Nothingness is not an object in the external world; it is an experience projected onto reality by human consciousness. According to Sartre, this can sometimes push all that exists into the background.

Sartre’s perspective suggests an interesting criterion for whether artificial intelligence can possess consciousness in the sense we understand it. ​Artificial intelligence is saturated with data; in fact, it is a hub for reproducing existing patterns. It processes data, patterns, definitions, labels, and existing entities. It operates entirely within the realm of “what is there.” It can successfully identify what an object is, or even state that a specific object is not present in an image. Yet, this state of “absence” remains a result drawn strictly from available data. Machine learning may utilize negative weights or inhibitory connections, but these are all parts of the model’s own mathematical representation. What I take from Sartre, however, is a distinction beyond this. For a human, nothingness is not merely a negative value; it is a unique experience constructed by consciousness.

​For instance, missing someone is precisely this kind of phenomenon. In Sartre’s example, I am trying to unpack the difference between the meaning of Pierre’s absence in a cafe and the lack of pixels belonging to Pierre. ​When you feed a photo of a cafe into an AI model, it identifies the tables, chairs, and people. If Pierre is not in the photo, the model simply returns Pierre: False. The non-presence of Pierre has no distinct ontological meaning for the model compared to any other object. ​Yet, when human consciousness walks into that same cafe, Pierre’s absence is not merely a “0”. That non-being can transform into an experience far more forceful and present than all the physical entities in the space. For humans, absence can sometimes become more visible than presence.

Do human memories not also rely on signals that once existed? Sometimes yes, but sometimes, it feels like no. I remain undecided on this point. Even so, in the framework proposed by Sartre, nothingness and non-being are not derived from a dataset. They form a distinct layer of meaning brought into the world by human consciousness.

​We are accustomed to defining everything through data, positives, and existing entities. So, grasping this concept of “nothingness” can be challenging. For example, when you are alone, you might feel bored; you want to do something, yet you abandon every option that comes to mind. Your friends might tell you, “You are thinking too negatively.” According to Sartre, it is precisely through this act of negation that human beings can gain freedom.

Recognizing the pure void left by something that is not there and making choices within that void is one of the most defining characteristics of human consciousness and freedom. In addition, it is surely a human condition to miss something. Maybe we should remember this more frequently.

​In summary, artificial intelligence establishes mathematical relationships among patterns within a dataset and defines what is absent strictly through these relationships. Humans, on the other hand, can live through the emptiness left by non-being. They can bring the absence of something that never existed or something that has departed into the world as an experience more commanding than existence itself. Perhaps Sartre’s concept of “nothingness” can help us propose a different benchmark for consciousness in AI debates. At the very least, we may now consider boredom not necessarily a bad thing.

Cite this post

Yazar, T. (2026, August 4). A Sartrean Criterion for AI Consciousness. designcoding. Retrieved November 19, 2026, from https://www.designcoding.net/a-sartrean-criterion-for-ai-consciousness/

Related Posts

Kant on a Tram

November 18, 2026

The Kantian readings and philosophical concepts in this text are not filtered through the lens of a philosophy professor, but rather emerge from curiosity started by questions that arose while watching the world from a tram window. Rather than a professional claim, it is just a thinking exercise about technology and architecture. While watching outside the tram from its window, I tried to remember the lectures I listened about Kant. I hate to discuss AI but the issue goes much…

Frege and Logicism

November 7, 2026

Today’s Digital Culture reading was on Frege. After the historical process shaped by thinkers like Hobbes and Leibniz, and by the effects of capitalism, I thought reading Frege would provide a good foundation before moving on to Wittgenstein. Gottlob Frege (1848-1925) was a German mathematician and logician. He spent most of his academic life at the University of Jena. Regarded as one of the founders of modern logic and analytic philosophy, Frege argued that the foundations of mathematics should be…

Work of Art in the Age of AI

September 19, 2026

In his groundbreaking 1935 text ‘The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,‘ Walter Benjamin questioned how photography and cinema radically transformed the nature of art. According to him, what made a work of art unique was its singular existence in time and space, its ‘aura’. Mechanical reproduction techniques shook this aura, detaching the work from its traditional context and offering it up for mass consumption. Today, we stand at a completely different threshold. Generative AI tools are…

Aletheia

November 14, 2026

My interest in polyhedra, Bézier curves, and other computer-generated geometric and mathematical abstractions does not come from a desire to model nature. What draws me to them is their sort of “alienness.” These are not objects we encounter ready-made in the natural world; they are constructed by the human mind. Yet once we construct them, they are no longer subject solely to our minds. The moment we define a tetrahedron, a Bézier curve, or any other geometric structure, relationships, necessities,…

Guitar Shape

November 2, 2026

Traditionally, when shaping a guitar form, a luthier relies on a combination of craftsmanship and precise geometric tools. This process involves mastering wood-bending techniques around rigid molds, guided by physical templates to achieve the desired acoustic and aesthetic curves. Curves, once more I love talking about this so much. Could my obsession with Bézier curves be OCD? The history of curved shape construction reflects a transformative journey from physical craftsmanship to sophisticated digital computation, primarily driven by the demands of…

  • Chapters

    • Algorithms
    • Discourses
    • Escapes
    • Fabrications
    • Studios
  • Explore

    • Table of Contents
    • Monthly Archive

    • All Keywords
    • #kant
    • #bezier-curve
    • #heidegger
    • #ontology
    • #digital-design
    • #polyhedra
    • #dedekind
    • #frege
    • #logic
    • #logicism
    • #philosophy-of-language
    • #russell
    • #wittgenstein
    • #b-spline
    • #curvature
    • #golden-ratio
    • #guitar
    • #music
    • #butterfly-curve
    • #grasshopper
  • Search

  • Support designcoding!

  • Enjoying designcoding? Support me on Patreon to keep it growing. Thank you!

  • copyright 2026 designcoding.net | about | privacy policy | end user license agreement